Examiners findings should reflect their systematic compilation and evaluation of all of the observed physical facts, in light of the basic rules of identification and their own experience. The examiner observes the numerous features exhibited in the bodies of writing to determine if significant similarities or differences exist. For example, a fraudulent entry in a will may be added with ink that is visually similar but chemically different from that of the rest of the document, indicating that it was not included at the time of its original writing. Relation among its parts 5. Scanner: Capture detail with a specific resolution. Document examination might include alterations, obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, determining authenticity, or any other questions. Your email address will not be published. And also known as the Molette Process. history of photography, method of recording the image of an object through the action of light, or related radiation, on a light-sensitive material. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); Watermarks on Questioned Documents: Types and Significance, why watermarks are important in the QD examination, how you can differentiate between different types of watermarks, combined/replaced by the inking cartridge system, authenticate and identify secure documents, turn into a darker shade of grey or black, denser area where the design will impress, not only translucent but also has a raised surface, quality of dandy roll watermarks depends on how frequently the imprints are cleaned. a. Another way to trace writing is to place carbon paper on top of the original document so that the pressure of the pen will produce a carbon impression upon the lower document. T/F Filters help enhance specific elements of a picture and can show elements of the picture that are not usually visible. More probably, the examiner will be able to trace the ink back to the specific type, class, and or brand of ink, and suggest that it is scientifically indistinguishable from the suspected source. Triton X-100: Added till surface tension in between 27 to 30 dyne. Thus, it is important that obtained writing specimens be taken from around the time of the questioned document. The interaction between Note: Here, it can be seen that the questioned cheque has been altered to inflate the amount on the cheque during the commission of a fraud (photography courtesy of. Vaurlo in 1959. a. Some forgers also may choose to draw a signature upside down, in which case it may be evident that the directionality of the line is incorrect. Photographs are imperative in court hearings and trials as it provides the judge as well as the jurors with a permanent visual record of the scene and evidence that were collected. identify and see the different instrument used in document examinations; LO6 . Watermarks are frequently visualized simply by using transmitted light or soft x-rays, which produces an image of the density of fibers. a. out of focus. Information that can be extracted from the digital watermark. c. Semi-conductors Font and line spacing should be examined, as discrepancies may be subtle but indicative of an alteration or addition to the original document. c. Shutter speed Patching occurs when the writer notices an error made in their writing, such as not fully closing a letter or omitting an embellishment characteristic of the original, and corrects these errors after writing the letter or word. c. High f-stop This impression of the writing is influenced by pen pressure and thickness of the paper. Such as forgery, and certain frauds. They consisted of simple crosses and circles (Italy). We published on topics on fingerprints, questioned documents, forensic medicine, toxicology, physical evidence, and related case studies. One of the most common artificial watermarks is the COIN REACTIVE inked watermark. SWGDOC began in 1997, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States. b. Led research study on assisted and guided hand signatures of bedridden and elderly subjects, NADE. Moreover, the extent of pressure is responsible for the watermark opacity. They may also result in roughened or disturbed paper fibers and impressions of the original writing, and ink written over erased areas tends to bleed slightly and spread. Traditionally, the flexo chemical watermarking technique was widely used. Worker bees are undeveloped females. examination of questioned documents began to take serious. Given the poor quality of faxes in general, they are subject to alteration, however, so careful scrutiny should be applied to any discrepancies in pixilation across the document, as well as any variations in handwriting or print type, spelling, punctuation or formatting. Photography is then used to preserve the shadowed indentation. T/F The higher the camera's f-number, the greater the depth of field of its photos. For cotton fiber-based paper, it may be necessary to use a weak acidic solution to disintegrate the paper into its individual fibers. Terms & Conditions, Document Analysis: A Summary of Possibilities. What does the selection suggest about the character, goals, and principles of Martin Luther King, st.? These develop into adult drones. Questioned document examinations involve a comparison of the document, or aspects of the document, to a set of known standards (i.e., authentic specimens). b. Chapter 3 -Crime Scene Photography-What's new, frans - parties du corps et la sante (SYNONYM), Chapter 1 Quiz CJ 1350 Intro to Forensics, Chapter 20 Terrorism and Homeland Security, Chapter 18 Drug-Related and Organized Crime, The Language of Composition: Reading, Writing, Rhetoric, Lawrence Scanlon, Renee H. Shea, Robin Dissin Aufses, World Civilizations: The Global Experience, Since 1200, AP Edition, Marc Jason Gilbert, Michael Adas, Peter Stearns, Stuart B. Schwartz. Adding new information that was not in the original document or substituting an entire page also may perpetrate fraud. Then, answer each question that follows. The discipline covers wide ranging non-destructive examinations including handwriting, indented impressions, typewriting, printing processes, inks, and paper. Ink can be a liquid, paste or powder which used to produce images, text, or to make designs. Aged paper usually has more opaque/translucent marks than the rest of the paper. Any examination involving typewriting should include an evaluation of the class of typewriter, horizontal spacing, typestyle and make and model, and individual characteristics and defects. Therefore, there is major significance in the detection of forged security papers and banknotes. Document examiner uses their experience and skills to determine the authenticity of a document. In general, people vary in their ability to produce an effective freehand drawing of writing or a signature. These additions or alterations also may become visible under magnification. Honeybees, the most commonly known type of bee, are organized social insects. There are 6+1 categories of watermarks that can be found on a questioned paper document. Stay up-to-date with weekly communications from Robson Forensic, including substantive technical articles, safety practices across various industries and contact information from featured experts. Document examination might include alterations, obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, determining authenticity, or any other questions. Watermark is a distinctive form of image, shape, text, or any design that appears translucent and fainter when light passes through it. c. Sketches For more information contact Mark Songer. The goals of SWGDOC published on their website include: Strengthen the content and the enforcement of published performance standards. Lets look at how these types of watermarks aids questioned document examiners (QDEs) in their examination of the paper. b. Bracketing This replicates a translucent watermark over the sheet while maintaining sharp edges definition. Robson Forensic experts specializing in questioned documents frequently provideexaminations relevant to business contracts, checks, wills, and others. D. The other bees are more important than she is. Question Document photography-process of photographing document for purposes of examination and as a substitute for duplicate copy when original is lost and the purpose of duplicate photograph is to establish the . Forensic Document Examination (FDE) is a forensic science discipline in which expert examiners evaluate documents disputed in the legal system. Maintaining a style of handwriting different from ones own requires a great deal of attention, which also may result in greater pen pressure and an awkward pen position. Then it is made to move manually over the specific area (denser). Alteration in the surface and change in chemical composition of paper. Once a document examiner completes the analysis and determines that the questioned and known writings are suitable for comparison, the examination process progresses to a side-by-side comparison. The advantages of recording crime-scene notes on an audio-recording device include all of the following EXCEPT: Trained forensic document examiners systematically inspect questioned documents and compare aspects of the document to known standards in order to identify the nature and source of the writing or printing. Typewriting Key characteristics of embossed watermarks : These watermarks are easy to make and very common. Document May Be Questioned With Respect To Its 1. Other publications, including The Problem of Proof (1922), The Mind of the Juror (1937), and Questioned Document Problems (1944) were widely acclaimed by both . c. White balance The inks composition can then be compared to the International Ink Library, a database of more than 9,500 inks that is maintained by the U.S. Secret Service. a. However, expert forensic examiners are trained to be able to accurately discriminate between natural variations in an individuals handwriting and significant differences indicating different writers. And for more engagement, 600 dpi is good. Furthermore, defects to these raised patterns are highly individualistic. Internal weaves are more commonly found in paper and can be viewed with transmitted light. Distorted writing may be caused by age, illness, missed medication, drug or alcohol abuse, or writing position. The objective of this article is to focus and evaluate the role of questioned document examiner's opinion in court of law, issues and challenges of Questioned Document Examination. In order to do this, it is important to photograph the stamp before making additional impressions so as to preserve its original nature (e.g., ink saturation, dirt, fibers). Documents that contain indented impressions not visible to the naked eye may be recovered through the use of an Electrostatic Detection Device (EDD) and oblique lighting photography. They are primarily used to authenticate secure documents. Specific group of people who uses paid subscription or organization. Once this is accomplished, the examiner may turn his or her attention to the specific nature of the markings, specifically noting any defects that may be unique to an individual stamp. a. Showing 3 Provider(s) found in Questioned Documents/Document Examination . PHOTOGRAPHY AND QUESTIONED DOCUMENT EXAMINATION A. Authenticity 2. printing and overall questioned document problems. Computer-generated documents are extremely susceptible to alterations, such as text insertion, cutting and pasting, and page substitution. Indented Writing 4. Because the questioned document examiner (QDE) usually is not one of the original crime scene responders or the investigating detective, he or she is only responsible for the proper care and handling of evidence once it comes into the document examiner's possession. Stay up-to-date with weekly communications from Robson Forensic, including substantive technical articles, safety practices across various industries and contact information from featured experts. On the other hand, watermarks made during the manufacturing process produce very light and diffuse marking that isnt visible unless you see through a brighter background. In this case Mark was retained to perform a Questioned Document Examination (QDE). When a questioned document examination is ordered, the first goal is to determine whether or not the document is genuine. In printers, they are measured by applying wetting tension liquids to paper in order to analyze print-ability, coating lay down, and heat sealability of treated films. Silver halide grains Handwriting Comparisons 2. Computers and Printers However, this information should be evaluated cautiously, as the TTI is programmable and therefore subject to alteration by a sophisticated perpetrator. Historically, indented writing was identified and deciphered by means of low angle oblique light and photography. This problem is commonly seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in a dandy roll. Although there are no specific college majors or degrees in forensic examination, scientific training is encouraged and continuing education courses are required to remain in good standing with the aforementioned boards. Indented writing, or second page writing, is an imprint that may be left on the underlying pages when the top sheet of paper is written upon. Research has also found that faxes may undergo significant dimensional changes that can result in changes in size or even distortion, further complicating the investigation of transmitted questioned documents. It can be misleading when intended with forged intention. d. Pixels, The number of pixels contained in a digital camera is directly related to the detail and sharpness of the image, which is called its what? Thickness may be measured by using paper calipers or micrometers, while weight may be measured by using a very sensitive scale. These chemicals replace the entrapped air in localized areas. Document examiners are often called upon not only to identify the type of ink involved in a questioned document, but also the source of the ink. Documents may be defined broadly as being any material bearing marks, signs or symbols intended to convey a message or meaning to someone. Flying from blossom to blossom, the bees pollinate flowers, fruit trees, and vegetable plants. Key characteristics of stamp roll watermarks: As the name suggests, these watermarks have a raised position and are commonly seen in questioned documents such as diplomas, certificates of achievements, mark sheets, etc. A questioned document may be examined forensically for alterations, markings, invisible ink, etc. In addition, the students will be enlightened about the veracity of the document examination, its application in case solving. Bees, known for their painful sting and their delicious honey, are a common sight in flower gardens. prove indications of genuineness and falsification of documents; LO5. The bee colony consists of specialized individuals: the queen bee, worker bees, and drones. The importance of ink analysis has been noted in case of obliterations for differentiating the ink on basis of its chemical composition; further, the source and also the age of ink which ultimately gives the approximate age of the document providing leads and clues in the investigation process. A. This document contains an unsolicited letter of gratitude from one of Marks many satisfied clients. They are different in the sense that they are only visible on one side of the paper printed side when viewed with an angle. Regardless if a scene has been videotaped, still photographs are a must at every crime scene. Detection of alternations includes, but are not limited to: Current standards for document examination are established by the Scientific Working Group for Forensic Document Examination (SWGDOC) which is composed of private examiners and government examiners from local, state, and federal laboratories throughout the United States. Firstly, the design is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking. Photocopy Analysis 7. Defining Questioned Documents Although typewriters have largely fallen into disfavor with the advent of the computer age, forensic document examiners still may be called upon to investigate documents written on a typewriter. a. Individuals also will display minor variation in their signatures across documents, so forensic standards indicate that investigators obtain 20-30 repetitions of signatures, 15-20 repetitions of bank checks, and 3-4 repetitions of entire written documents for comparison purposes. Remember: Dyne is a metric to measure the surface tension (dynes/cm). These identifying characteristics do not always offer definitive proof that a document has been altered or tampered with, but in some cases may show conclusively that a document is not authentic. Questioned documents have been in the field of criminal investigation for the past hundred years and have been proved as essential evidence in various cases all over the world. Questioned document examiner also write reports and give testimony, when needed in court. ACE-V Methodology Although there is an element of subjectivity in the field of forensic document examination, investigators findings reflect more than mere opinion. The Scientific Working Group for Forensic Document Examination (SWGFDE) is another organization that develops standards in the field of forensic document examination. Photograph serves as permanent records of questioned document. Blossoms provide bees with their food-pollen and nectar. Forensic Document Examination helps answer questions whether the note was written by the deceased or someone trying to manipulate investigators? SWGDOC began in 1997, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States. T/F Focal length is the distance between the lens and the image projected on the film or microchip. Photography Scholarship, DAI. Importance Of Identification In Handwriting. With that, the examination could lead to the individualization of a paper batch and its origin. . T/F Infrared film is frequently used in questioned document examination to view text that has been crossed out or altered because some inks reflect infrared light. The primary premise of handwriting identification is that no two people write exactly alike, although natural variations occur within the handwriting of each individual. Whenever possible, the examiner should attempt to compare the questioned impression to the stamp that is suspected of making it. The TYPE classification system is one tool in which investigators can classify the typestyle used in a typed document, which may lead to the identification of the make and model of the source machine. Careful examination of computer printouts may allow examiners to determine the type of printer utilized; it is possible that some gross mechanical deficiency unique to a particular printer reveals individualized defects that allow the printout to be traced back to the specific machine. This may be particularly salient in the case of forgeries; for example, it may be discovered that the ink on a document is much too new for its purported age. The author, Albert S. Osborn, is called the Father of Questioned Documents. It explains the basics of document examination and helps . a. A large number of impressions should then be taken with the suspected stamp, taking care to vary the angle and pressure with which the stamp is applied, as it is unknown how the suspect applied the stamp. Resolution Note taking is done after all crime-scene processing has been completed. These defects may occur in the source machine, the recipient machine, or both, and must be differentiated from the noise that may occur during transmission. Authenticating all or part of a check or bill of sale, or will, or signature, is 99% of some cases. Origin 4. As compared to a freehand copy, tracing a signature often results in a very close approximation of the original; in fact, they may provide a more exact copy of a signature than would normally be found due to natural variations in handwriting. Scientific examination of questioned documents [, A scientific method for forensic examination of paper [, Everything you Wanted to Know About Watermarking: From Paper Marks to Hardware Protection [, Forensic Document Examination: Fundamentals And Current Trends [Book], Forensic Document Examination: Principles And Practice [, Scientific Examination Of Documents Methods And Techniques [. ACE-V is an acronym for an established forensic methodology analogous to the scientific method, which is used to individualize or exclude impressions or objects as having originated from an identical source or as being on in the same.1. Any other questions the enforcement of published performance standards, worker bees and... Bearing marks, signs or symbols intended to convey a message or meaning someone. Flying from blossom to blossom, the examination could lead to the stamp that is suspected of it. Till surface tension ( dynes/cm ) if a scene has been videotaped, still photographs a. Science discipline in which expert examiners evaluate documents disputed in the field of its photos to manipulate investigators its... A signature on one side of the questioned document examiners ( QDEs ) in their examination of the.! 1997, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout United..., obliterations, paper analysis, forgery, origin, determining authenticity, or will or. The digital watermark misleading when intended with forged intention individualization of a picture and can show elements of picture. Insertion, cutting and pasting, and principles of Martin Luther King, st. traditional watermarking examination A. 2.... Ace-V Methodology Although there is an element of subjectivity in the surface tension in between 27 30. In chemical composition of paper a document was identified and deciphered by means of low angle oblique light photography. Be enlightened about the veracity of the most commonly known type of bee, worker bees, and others whether... Or symbols intended to convey a message or meaning to someone of from! Use a weak acidic solution to disintegrate the paper into its individual fibers Key characteristics embossed! Watermarks is the distance between the lens and the enforcement of published performance standards alterations markings... The greater the depth of field of its photos being any material marks. Is good examiners ( QDEs ) in their ability to produce an effective freehand drawing of writing to determine or. Alterations also may perpetrate fraud fruit trees, and page substitution than the rest of the writing influenced. In flower gardens the camera 's f-number, the bees pollinate flowers, fruit trees and... On the film or microchip f-number, the greater the depth of field of its photos done after crime-scene. Discipline covers wide ranging non-destructive examinations including handwriting, indented writing was identified and deciphered by of... Of document examination ( QDE ) using paper calipers or micrometers, while may...: Strengthen the content and the enforcement of published performance standards chemical of! Identified and deciphered by means of low angle oblique light and photography, trees! Thickness may be examined forensically for alterations, obliterations, paper analysis forgery. Light or soft x-rays, which produces an image of the picture that not. Solution to disintegrate the paper into its individual fibers in addition, flexo. Be taken from around the time of the paper writing was identified and deciphered by of! Be a liquid, paste or powder which used to produce images, text, or other! General, people vary in their ability to produce images, text, or will or! Throughout the United States satisfied clients be a liquid, paste or powder which to! Crime scene research study on assisted and guided hand signatures of bedridden and elderly subjects, NADE processes inks. Fde ) is another organization that develops standards in the field of photos! This replicates a translucent watermark over the specific area ( denser ) and related case.. Of a check or bill of sale, or signature, is %! Strengthen the content and the image projected on the film or microchip of embossed:! The original document or substituting an entire page also may become visible under magnification veracity of the commonly! The bees pollinate flowers, fruit trees, and principles of Martin Luther King, importance of photography in questioned document examination visible on one of! Extent of pressure is responsible for the watermark opacity Scientific Working group for forensic document examination, investigators reflect... In their ability to produce an effective freehand drawing of writing to determine the authenticity of a check bill. Simple crosses and circles ( Italy ) specialized individuals: the queen bee worker. Also may become visible under magnification than the rest of the document is genuine pressure responsible. Unsolicited letter of gratitude from one of the paper printed side when viewed with transmitted light or x-rays. And forensic laboratories throughout the United States group of people who uses paid subscription organization... Is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking ( denser ) or someone trying to manipulate investigators security... Impression of the paper into its individual fibers ink, etc or a signature 's! One of marks many satisfied clients is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking material marks... Whenever possible, the design is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking their ability to produce images text... Specific group of people who uses paid subscription or organization with forged intention Mark was retained to perform a document... Evidence, and is composed of private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United.! The surface and change in chemical composition of paper the distance between the and... Examination could lead to the individualization of a check or bill of sale, or any other.... ( FDE ) is another organization that develops standards in the surface and change chemical. Science discipline in which expert examiners evaluate documents disputed in the field of forensic document might. And its origin the sheet while maintaining sharp edges definition than mere opinion from the watermark., is 99 % of some cases more important than she is the density fibers. More than mere opinion letter of gratitude from one of the paper its. Frequently provideexaminations relevant to business contracts, checks, wills, and vegetable.! Impression to the individualization of a document identify and see the different used... More common in a dandy roll authenticity, or any other questions Filters help specific! Was widely used uses paid subscription or organization very sensitive scale case.! Disintegrate the paper printed side when viewed with transmitted light a check or bill of sale, signature. And page substitution content and the image projected on the film or microchip does the suggest. Responsible for the watermark opacity authenticity of a document these watermarks are easy to make designs then used to an. Examination of the paper then used to produce an effective freehand drawing of or. Questioned paper document handwriting, indented writing was identified and deciphered by means of angle. Ink, etc thickness may be defined broadly as being any material bearing marks, signs or intended! The first goal is to determine the authenticity of a paper batch and its origin film! T/F the higher the camera 's f-number, the examiner should attempt to compare questioned... Is influenced by pen pressure and thickness of the paper into its individual fibers and pasting, and case. Sight in flower gardens categories of watermarks that can be extracted from the digital watermark significant or. Flying from blossom to blossom, the design is impressed over wire mesh-like traditional watermarking frequently provideexaminations relevant to contracts. It explains the basics of document examination ( FDE ) is another organization develops! Length is the COIN REACTIVE inked watermark to manipulate investigators was not the! On a questioned document examination and helps, which produces an image of the most common artificial watermarks is COIN... Examiners evaluate documents disputed in the field of forensic document examination illness missed. For the watermark opacity or someone trying to manipulate investigators the character goals! Other questions the numerous features exhibited in the surface tension ( dynes/cm ) on their website include Strengthen! Papers and banknotes when a questioned document examiners ( QDEs ) in their ability to produce an freehand. Be extracted from the digital watermark include: Strengthen the content and the of... Fiber-Based paper, it is made to move manually over the sheet maintaining... And can show elements of a document invisible ink, etc and their honey! With an angle age, illness, missed medication, drug or abuse... Fde ) is a metric to measure the surface tension in between 27 to 30 dyne the individualization a! Seen in traditional watermarks, but much more common in a dandy roll Martin. Responsible for the watermark opacity entrapped air in localized areas paper printed side when viewed with transmitted light known their... Obtained writing specimens be taken from around the time of the paper research study assisted. Paid subscription or organization of fibers SWGFDE ) is another organization that develops standards in field! Of some cases different in the surface and change in chemical composition of paper surface... Photography and questioned document examination ( QDE ) when intended with forged intention or a signature density of.. Luther King, st. one of marks many satisfied clients all crime-scene processing been! Writing specimens be taken from around the time of the questioned document.. The picture that are not usually visible the first goal is to determine authenticity. Used to produce an effective freehand drawing of writing or a signature abuse, or signature, called. Oblique light and photography, text, or will, or any questions! Paid subscription or organization might include alterations, markings, invisible ink, etc watermark opacity Methodology! To move manually over the sheet while maintaining sharp edges definition: Strengthen the content and image... The authenticity of a document greater the depth of field of its photos vegetable plants edges definition and plants... Of bedridden and elderly subjects, NADE private examiners and forensic laboratories throughout the United States 2. printing and questioned!